The Boys in the
Bunkhouse: Chapters 1-4
The
opening chapters of the book, The Boys in
the Bunkhouse, function as an introduction to the overarching story of the
book; the story of men, “the boys”, who suffer from intellectual disabilities.
The book is the story of how these men were treated by their families and
society. These first few chapters take a lot of time to describe the different
men that the book follows. “The boys” are named, described, and quoted. Their
backgrounds are mentioned, their family life before the state school, and their
personalities. Even some of their family members have been interviewed to help
give the reader a better sense of who these men are. The author of this book
lets the reader know more about these men in the first few chapters of their
story then most people have probably cared to known about them their whole
lives. While the reader learns about the men in the first few chapters, they
also begin to learn how they have been neglected, scorned, abused and been
looked down on by society and their families. One example of this is that the
state school some of the boys attended in Texas, when they were younger, was a “renovated”
POW camp. Or that when they left the state school many of the boys ended up
working on T.H’s farm doing work, inseminating turkeys, that no one else wanted
to do.
One
thing that really stuck out to me while starting The Boys in the Bunkhouse is how society’s view of these men, with intellectual
disabilities, never really changed over time, even though our standards for how
to help people with this type disability changed. The book shows that in our
early history people with intellectual disabilities were treated very poorly,
especially in some of the state schools. People were afraid, confused, and
ashamed about people with intellectual disabilities. They looked down on people
with this struggle and hid them away in institutions or state schools. Even
later, when the movement came to integrate intellectually disabled people into
society, I feel like, in general, society still held similar views on people
with this disability. From reading about T.H’s turkey farm it seems like the
move to “integrate” these men into society still pivoted around what was best
for a community or and individual, the “normal” members of society, so to
speak. When our society was at a loss of what to do with intellectually
disabled men and women, we hid them away so we would not have to deal with
them. When it became more appropriate (and convenient) to “integrate” these men
and women into society, we did this by giving them lower standards of living
then the rest of society, the work no one wanted to do, and less pay for this
work. I feel like society is still not always thinking about what is really
best for these men and women, unless it is also best for everyone else. The
descriptions of these men in the book brought these individual men to life for
me. They became more than just a group of people labeled as disabled or
intellectually impaired. They had families, personalities, and stories. I think
we get to see this individuality and uniqueness of the men in the story The Boys in the Bunkhouse. Consequently,
we need to remember this is true with all people who have been put into groups
labels, or categories by our society.
Although it was very sad to read about the personal stories of each of "the boys" it was interesting to learn more about each of the men. We were able to read about their family history, and why they were in this particular situation. I agree, I think that our society was very unsure how to treat those with intellectual disabilities. When they were finally allowed in the society they were still treated unfairly, and this book shows a specific example. Throughout this book I think we will be able to see several different ways that those with disabilities are abused and neglected.
ReplyDeleteWhen reading the book I really did not get sad,I felt like it got me mad and this is because people think it is okay to treat people with intellectual disabilities how the owners treated "the boys" on the plant. It is hard to read how "the boys" were treated and how much they were abused just because of their disability. i feel like once family's as whole learn how to treat their loved ones with an intellectual disability, then us and society will learn how to treat them as equals.
ReplyDeleteIt makes me wonder how many people with disabilities that have been born in the last 10 years would have been treated very differently had they been born 60 years ago. The push for social justice and equality is so important so that these things don't happen to our vulnerable people
ReplyDelete